The cheapest paid AI writing tool of the three is QuillBot, whose Premium tier is listed at $4.17/mo in the AI-Mind AI Tool Database, followed by Grammarly Pro at $12/mo and ProWritingAid's Premium Pro at $12/mo — though all three also offer a free tier, so the real answer depends on which job you need done.
The honest starting point is that "cheapest" only means something once you know whether you're paying for rewriting, correcting, or generating. Pick by job first, then compare prices inside that job. If you buy on price alone, you'll likely end up paying for a tool that's cheap at something you don't need.
Here's the mechanism behind that. These tools are priced for different jobs, and each one is strong at one and weak at the others. Rewriting means taking text you already wrote and rephrasing it — that's QuillBot's core strength.
Correcting means checking grammar, style, and structure as you write — that's Grammarly's and ProWritingAid's territory. Generating means producing new text from a prompt — none of these three is built primarily for that, which is why people often bolt on a separate chat tool and end up with two bills instead of one.
According to the AI-Mind AI Tool Database, Grammarly is categorized as a writing tool with context-aware style adjustment for academic, business, and email tones, plus logic structure optimization and Smart Drafts. ProWritingAid is also a writing tool, with a premium lifetime option at $399 — a one-time payment rather than a subscription.
QuillBot is listed as an AI platform by QuillBot in the same writing category. The database snapshot behind these numbers was most recently verified on 2026-09-18, and it covers 360 AI tools in total.
A concrete example makes the job split clearer. Suppose — and this is a hypothetical scenario, not tested usage data — you write 40 client emails and two blog posts a month. A rewriter like QuillBot helps when you've already drafted the blog posts and want them tighter; it does much less for a 90-word email you wrote in two minutes.
A corrector like Grammarly Pro helps across all 42 items because it works inside the writing surface. If most of your volume is short-form email, the corrector earns its $12/mo; if most of your volume is long-form drafts you rewrite repeatedly, the rewriter at $4.17/mo earns its place.
Same person, same month, different winner — because the job changed, not the price. That's the decision rule: count your long-form drafts versus your short-form messages, and buy for whichever number is bigger.
Now the limits, which matter more than the prices. First, these figures are a verified snapshot, not a live feed — pricing changes often, so check the vendor's own page before you subscribe. Second, ProWritingAid's listing includes both a monthly Premium at $30/mo and a yearly Premium at $360/yr, plus a Premium Pro at $12/mo and $144/yr; the lifetime tiers at $399 and $699 only pay off if you'll still be using the tool years from now, and they don't cover future feature tiers.
Third, a free tier can be the genuinely cheapest option — all three list one — but free tiers usually cap how much you can check or rewrite per day, so the ceiling arrives exactly when you're busiest. Fourth, none of these three solves generation, so if drafting from scratch is your bottleneck, no amount of price comparison here will fix it.
Finally, the editorial ratings in the database — 4.5/5 for Grammarly, 4.5/5 for QuillBot, and 4.4/5 for ProWritingAid — are close enough that they shouldn't decide it for you. The job should.
One tip that saves real money: before upgrading, run your own text through each free tier for a week and note which one you actually open without thinking. That habit, not the price tag, tells you which job you're really paying for. If you want to see where free stops being enough, this site's breakdown of the best free AI writing helper option in 2026 walks through that ceiling.
And if your real problem is that you're paying for a rewriter when you needed a generator, the cost of prompt-only tools is worth reading before you add a second subscription.